Svalna is a partner in a new research project funded by Formas, the Swedish Research Council for Sustainable Development, where we join Chalmers University of Technology, KTH Royal Institute of Technology and Statistics Sweden (SCB) to examine a question that has long slipped under the radar in carbon accounting: when a household spends more on a category of goods, is it because they buy more – or because they buy better?
Most methods for estimating consumption-based emissions assume that emissions scale with the amount of money spent in a given category. A pair of trousers that costs 2,000 SEK is thus assumed to cause four times the emissions of a pair that costs 500 SEK. Anyone who shops knows this is not quite right, but until now the data to do anything about it has been lacking.
If the proportionality assumption is wrong, it is wrong in a systematic way. Households that pay more per unit – often for more durable, repairable or long-lived products – are assigned emissions that are too high, while households that buy cheap and often are assigned emissions that are too low. This affects everything from how we describe carbon inequality between income groups to how we evaluate policies targeting short-lived goods, such as the proposals now being debated in the EU and France on ultra-fast fashion and the right to repair.
The project approaches the problem from two directions at once: variation in how households actually consume, and variation in emission intensity between firms and products within the same category. Connecting these two perspectives has not been done before at this scale. The results will provide better estimates of how carbon footprints vary with income, and a stronger basis for judging whether quality-oriented policies actually work – and whether they have public support.
The project runs 2026–2031 and includes a PhD position at Chalmers.
Svalna's role concerns the part that is hardest to get at: linking firm-level data from Statistics Sweden (SCB) with detailed trade statistics to see how emissions differ between suppliers and product variants. We have already shown that the approach works for the service sector, and in this project we extend it to manufacturing and agriculture – with textiles, furniture and vehicles as particularly interesting cases.
What we learn in this project feeds straight into our own system. The better we understand the difference between price and volume, the more accurate the picture becomes for our customers – not least for organisations that deliberately choose to buy more expensive but more sustainable, and who today risk being "penalised" for it in the calculations. In the longer run, it is about being able to say something more precise about what a procurement strategy actually means for the climate, rather than just counting invoice totals.
More to follow as the project progresses.